| 1910: Fiction |
 | 1 | The Rosary | Barclay, Florence |
| | 2 | A Modern Chronicle | Churchill, Winston |
| | 3 | The Wild Olive | King, Basil |
| | 4 | Max | Thurston, Katherine Cecil |
| | 5 | The Kingdom of Slender Swords | Rives, Hallie Erminie |
| | 6 | Simon the Jester | Locke, William J. |
| | 7 | Lord Loveland Discovers America | Williamson, C. N. and A. M. |
| | 8 | The Window at the White Cat | Rinehart, Mary Roberts |
| | 9 | Molly Make-Believe | Abbott, Eleanor |
| | 10 | When a Man Marries | Rinehart, Mary Roberts |
| 1911: Fiction |
| | 1 | The Broad Highway | Farnol, Jeffrey |
| | 2 | The Prodigal Judge | Kester, Vaughan |
| 3 | The Winning of Barbara Worth | Wright, Harold Bell |
| | 4 | Queed | Harrison, Henry Sydnor |
| | 5 | The Harvester | Porter, Gene Stratton |
| | 6 | The Iron Woman | Margaret Deland |
| | 7 | The Long Roll | Johnston, Mary |
| | 8 | Molly Make-Believe | Abbott, Eleanor |
| 9 | The Rosary | Barclay, Florence |
| | 10 | The Common Law | Chambers, Robert W. |
| 1912: Fiction |
| | 1 | The Harvester | Porter, Gene Stratton |
| | 2 | The Street Called Straight | King, Basil |
| | 3 | Their Yesterdays | Wright, Harold Bell |
| | 4 | The Melting of Molly | Daviess, Maria Thompson |
| | 5 | A Hoosier Chronicle | Nicholson, Meredith |
| 6 | The Winning of Barbara Worth | Wright, Harold Bell |
| | 7 | The Just and the Unjust | Kester, Vaughan |
| | 8 | The Net | Beach, Rex |
| | 9 | Tante | Sedgwick, Anne Douglas |
| | 10 | Fran | Ellis, J. Breckenridge |
| 1912: Non-Fiction |
| | 1 | The Promised Land | Antin, Mary |
| | 2 | The Montessori Method | Montessori, Maria |
| | 3 | South America | Bryce, James |
| | 4 | A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil | Addams, Jane |
| | 5 | Three Plays | Brieux, Eugene |
| | 6 | Your United States | Bennett, Arnold |
| | 7 | Creative Evolution | Bergson, Henri |
| | 8 | How to Live on Twenty-Four Hours a Day | Bennett, Arnold |
| | 9 | Woman and Labor | Schreiner, Olive |
| | 10 | Mark Twain | Paine, Albert Bigelow |
| 1913: Fiction |
| | 1 | The Inside of the Cup | Churchill, Winston |
| | 2 | V. V.'s Eyes | Harrison, Henry Sydnor |
| | 3 | Laddie | Porter, Gene Stratton |
| | 4 | The Judgment House | Parker, Sir Gilbert |
| | 5 | Heart of the Hills | Fox, John Jr. |
| | 6 | The Amateur Gentleman | Farnol, Jeffrey |
| | 7 | The Woman Thou Gavest Me | Caine, Hall |
| 8 | Pollyanna | Porter, Eleanor H. |
| | 9 | The Valiants of Virginia | Rives, Hallie Erminie |
| | 10 | T. Tembarom | Burnett, Frances Hodgson |
| 1913: Non-Fiction |
| | 1 | Crowds | Lee, Gerald Stanley |
| | 2 | Germany and the Germans | Collier, Price |
| | 3 | Zone Policeman 88 | Franck, Harry A. |
| | 4 | The New Freedom | Wilson, Woodrow |
| | 5 | South America | Bryce, James |
| | 6 | Your United States | Bennett, Arnold |
| | 7 | The Promised Land | Antin, Mary |
| | 8 | Auction Bridge To-Day | Work, Milton C. |
| | 9 | Three Plays | Brieux, Eugene |
| | 10 | Psychology and Industrial Efficiency | Munsterberg, Hugo |
| 1914: Fiction |
| | 1 | The Eyes of the World | Wright, Harold Bell |
| 2 | Pollyanna | Porter, Eleanor H. |
| | 3 | The Inside of the Cup | Churchill, Winston |
| | 4 | The Salamander | Johnson, Owen |
| 5 | The Fortunate Youth | Locke, William J. |
| | 6 | T. Tembarom | Burnett, Frances Hodgson |
| | 7 | Penrod | Tarkington, Booth |
| | 8 | Diane of the Green Van | Dalrymple, Leona |
| | 9 | The Devil's Garden | Maxwell, W. B. |
| | 10 | The Prince of Graustark | McCutcheon, George Barr |
| 1915: Fiction |
| 1 | The Turmoil | Tarkington, Booth |
| | 2 | A Far Country | Churchill, Winston |
| 3 | Michael O'Halloran | Porter, Gene Stratton |
| 4 | Pollyanna Grows Up | Porter, Eleanor H. |
| 5 | K | Rinehart, Mary Roberts |
| | 6 | Jaffery | Locke, William J. |
| | 7 | Felix O'Day | Smith, F. Hopkinson |
| | 8 | The Harbor | Poole, Ernest |
| | 9 | The Lone Star Ranger | Grey, Zane |
| | 10 | Angela's Business | Harrison, Henry Sydnor |
| 1916: Fiction |
| 1 | Seventeen | Tarkington, Booth |
| | 2 | When a Man's a Man | Wright, Harold Bell |
| | 3 | Just David | Porter, Eleanor H. |
| | 4 | Mr. Britling Sees It Through | Wells, H. G. |
| | 5 | Life and Gabriella | Glasgow, Ellen |
| | 6 | The Real Adventure | Webster, Henry Kitchell |
| | 7 | Bars of Iron | Dell, Ethel M. |
| | 8 | Nan of Music Mountain | Spearman, Frank H. |
| | 9 | Dear Enemy | Webster, Jean |
| | 10 | The Heart of Rachael | Norris, Kathleen |
| 1917: Fiction |
| | 1 | Mr. Britling Sees It Through | Wells, H. G. |
| | 2 | The Light in the Clearing | Bacheller, Irving |
| | 3 | The Red Planet | Locke, William J. |
| | 4 | The Road to Understanding | Porter, Eleanor H. |
| 5 | Wildfire | Grey, Zane |
| | 6 | Christine | Cholmondeley, Alice |
| | 7 | In the Wilderness | Hichens, Robert S. |
| | 8 | His Family | Poole, Ernest |
| | 9 | The Definite Object | Farnol, Jeffrey |
| | 10 | The Hundredth Chance | Dell, Ethel M. |
| 1917: Non-Fiction |
| | 1 | Rhymes of a Red Cross Man | Service, Robert W. |
| | 2 | The Plattsburg Manual | Ellis, O. O. and E. B. Garey |
| | 3 | Raymond | Lodge, Sir Oliver |
| | 4 | Poems of Seeger, Alan | Seeger, Alan |
| | 5 | God the Invisible King | Wells, H. G. |
| | 6 | Laugh and Live | Fairbanks, Douglas |
| | 7 | Better Meals for Less Money | Green, Mary |
| 1918: Fiction |
| 1 | The U. P. Trail | Grey, Zane |
| | 2 | The Tree of Heaven | Sinclair, May |
| | 3 | The Amazing Interlude | Rinehart, Mary Roberts |
| | 4 | Dere Mable | Streeter, Edward |
| | 5 | Oh, Money! Money! | Porter, Eleanor H. |
| | 6 | Greatheart | Dell, Ethel M. |
| | 7 | The Major | Connor, Ralph |
| | 8 | The Pawns Count | Oppenheim, E. Phillips |
| 9 | A Daughter of the Land | Porter, Gene Stratton |
| | 10 | Sonia | McKenna, Stephen |
| 1918: Non-Fiction |
| | 1 | Rhymes of a Red Cross Man | Service, Robert W. |
| | 2 | Treasury of War Poetry | Clark, G. H. |
| | 3 | With the Colors | Appleton, Everard J. |
| | 4 | Recollections | Morley, Viscount |
| | 5 | Laugh and Live | Fairbanks, Douglas |
| | 6 | Mark Twain's Letters | Paine, Albert Bigelow, editor |
| | 7 | Adventures and Letters of Davis, Richard Harding | Davis, Richard Harding |
| | 8 | Over Here | Guest, Edgar |
| | 9 | Diplomatic Days | O'Shaughnessy, Edith |
| | 10 | Poems of Seeger, Alan | Seeger, Alan |
| 1919: Fiction |
| 1 | The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse | Ibanez, V. Blasco |
| 2 | The Arrow of Gold | Conrad, Joseph |
| | 3 | The Desert of Wheat | Grey, Zane |
| | 4 | Dangerous Days | Rinehart, Mary Roberts |
| | 5 | The Sky Pilot in No Man's Land | Connor, Ralph |
| 6 | The Re-Creation of Brian Kent | Wright, Harold Bell |
| | 7 | Dawn | Porter, Gene Stratton |
| | 8 | The Tin Soldier | Bailey, Temple |
| | 9 | Christopher and Columbus | "Elizabeth" |
| | 10 | In Secret | Chambers, Robert W. |
| 1919: Non-Fiction |
| | 1 | The Education of Henry Adams | Adams, Henry |
| | 2 | The Years Between | Kipling, Rudyard |
| | 3 | Belgium | Whitlock, Brand |
| | 4 | The Seven Purposes | Cameron, Margaret |
| | 5 | In Flanders Fields | McCrae, John |
| | 6 | Bolshevism | Spargo, John |